Evidence from church ordinance records proves that Lucia Ann traveled to Utah by 1855. She was rebaptized in the American Fork Ward on 21 October 1856 along with her husband, Thomas, and a another person by the name of Mary Bishop. Mary's identity has not been confirmed. Further research is needed to determine the year Lucia Ann came to Utah and the name of the company she traveled with. In some records, her name is recorded as "Lucy Ann." Her death date is confirmed by the inscription on her gravestone.